American Church in Paris - Sermons

ACP HOME - Sermon Archives - Past ACP Sermons

“Let Loving Hearts Enthrone Him” by Dr. Alex Aronis

30 December 2007

Texts:  Micah 5:2-6a; Matthew 2:1-12 


© 2007 Alex Aronis


We’ve had  a wonderful celebration of Christmas at the American Church in Paris.  A number of persons have told me how special our Christmas Eve Candle Light Services were for them this past Monday.

We have  sung the Christmas Carols, decorated the Christmas trees,  exchanged Christmas gifts, read the Christmas Cards and Christmas newsletters;  and now we turn to Matthew 2 to consider what it all means. We’re going to pause this morning, after all of the singing and celebrating, to ask ourselves how we are going to respond to the birth of Christ.

Our opening hymn sets the stage because it begins with a question.  “What Child Is This?” The hymn was written by Rev. William Dix. A beautiful and ancient English melody, Greensleeves, was attached to the words. The tune dates back to Shakespeare and even earlier.
“What Child is this who, laid to rest,
On Mary’s lap is sleeping? Most of the hymns begin, not with a question, but with a declarative statement. “Joy to the world! The Lord is come!” “O Come all ye faithful, Joyful and Triumphant!” “Hark the Herald Angels Sing, 'Glory to the newborn King.’”  “Angels we have heard on High! Sweetly Singing O’er the Plains,” “Oh Little town of Bethlehem, how still we see thee lie.”
All positive statements. But William Dix asks a question --  “What Child is this who, laid to rest,
On Mary’s lap is sleeping?
Whom angels greet with anthems sweet,
While shepherds watch are keeping?” When you have a question it is natural to pause, so that you can give an intelligent response.

The carol goes on to ask why it was necessary for the child to suffer? Why the nails, the spear, the cross? In a very beautiful way, Dix raises this huge question. And it is such a huge question that we need time to think it through. We need space between the question and answer.
We often find these spaces -- these pauses -- in the Bible. They allow us to think, to ponder, to decide. How often Jesus says, “He who has ears to hear, let him hear.” Jesus wants us to really listen to his words, to let them sink in, let them touch our inner being. When we have understood, when we are ready, then, we are to give our answer, our response.

Let’s get started by taking a few moments to look at the 2nd chapter of Matthew, the narrative upon which William Dix based his carol. Matthew, writing to a Jewish audience, anchors his account of the birth of Jesus in Jewish history, and tells us that Jesus was born during the time of Herod the King.

Herod was known as Herod the Great. He ruled for 37 years, and during that time built theaters, amphitheaters, monuments, pagan altars, fortresses-- like the fortress of Masada next to the Dead Sea. His greatest work was the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem, often referred to as Herod's Temple. It took 88 years to build and was torn down in 70 AD when the Romans under Titus completely destroyed Jerusalem. It was that temple that Jesus referred to when he said, “Not one stone will be left on another; everyone will be thrown down”-- 40 years after Jesus made that prediction, it was fulfilled literally -- one stone ws not left on another.

The text tells us that Wise Men came from the East, asking “Where is the one who has been born King of the Jews for we have seen his star in the East and have come to worship him.”  Some say that the star was the conjunctions of two planets, Jupiter and Saturn.  The wise men were probably astrologers, perhaps from Persia or southern Arabia, and they had come to worship the King of the Jews.

Some wonder: why did God guide the magi by a star?  I think it’s because God was leading them in accordance with their religious understanding and experience. God works with people in terms of where they are.  

Please do not think that this story is advising us to look to the heavens and find direction through astrology. God does not want us to consult with the stars. God rules over the stars. God’s invites us to consult directly with him. In Jeremiah 33:3 -- some people refer to this as God's telephone number -- Jeremiah 33:3 --  He invites us to “Call to me and I will answer you and tell you great an unsearchable things you do not know.” There is no need for Christians to seek ambivalent messages from the stars.

When King Herod heard all of this, he was disturbed. Never mind that the King of the Jews was only a baby, and that Herod was far too old to worry about a baby growing up to take his throne. Herod was obsessively suspicious, and ruthless in dealing with threats to his kingdom.  He  murdered his wife, his three sons, his mother-in-law, uncle and many others -- not to mention the babies in Bethlehem.

Not knowing the Old Testament, Herod called together the chief priests and teachers of the law. He wanted information about this new born King. “Where is this child to be born?” he asked. The teachers of the Hebrew Bible turned to the book of Micah, written 700 years before Christ. The Prophet Micah could have pointed to any nation in the world, he pointed to Palestine; he could have pointed to any one of the 12 tribes, he pointed to Judah; it could have pointed to any one of the many towns and villages in Judah, he pointed to Bethlehem and said, “There-- in that little village, in the land of Judah, some day, “shall come a ruler who will govern my people Israel.” Seven hundred years later it happened, just as he said.

Why Bethlehem? Because David had lived in Bethlehem, and the Jews believed that the Messiah would be in David’s family line, as Joseph was. St. Luke tells us, Joseph was of the house and lineage of David.  And even though Jesus was not the physical son of Joseph, Jesus being the legal son of Joseph was therefore a descendant of David.

Let’s summarize: the Wise men -- led by a star -- came to Jerusalem looking for the King of the Jews.  The Hebrew Bible was opened. And only then was the specific location of the Christ child provided. Do you see the progression? First God uses natural revelation, a star. And then he uses Biblical revelation to tell the Wise Men that the child would be born in Bethlehem. We need Biblical revelation--the Word of God -- to encourage us, to correct us, to build us up, to guide us.

The amazing thing is that when the scribes told the Wise Men where the Messiah was to be born, no one other than the Wise men made the journey to Bethlehem. It was only 5 or so miles away, -- 8 kilometers. Why didn’t others go? Were they afraid of Herod? Probably so

Not that anyone else was invited to the birthday party. When you have a baby you don’t want  hordes of people around. You want to hand-pick your visitors. To witness the birth of his Son, God selected humble shepherds and non-Jewish dignitaries. These were the invited guests.  And when these wise men saw the child, they fell before the child-- the text is very Christocentric -- not the mother and child -- but specifically, the text says they fell before the child. And made a formal gesture of adoration. They worshipped him, and gave him, the Christ child, their gifts: gold incense and myrrh.

In one of Garrison Kellor’s Christmas programs, Garrison made fun of the gifts of the Wise Men. He talked about how impractical they were. Aside from the gold, who could use incense and myrrh?  Garrison Kellor knows how to entertain an audience, but he was misinformed.  The gifts of incense and myrrh were fragrances, and in the first century, fragrances were as good as cash. So the gold and the fragrances together enabled Joseph, Mary and the child to go to Egypt and to stay there until they were told to return to Israel and then to Nazareth in Galilee.  

Four times in this Christmas Story, Joseph is addressed by angels, and each time he does what they tell him to do. How different Joseph was from so many who resist the voices of good angels.

Charles Dickens wrote the great classic The Christmas Carol, about Ebenezer Scrooge, the cold-hearted, tight-fisted, selfish man, who despised Christmas and all things which make people happy. In that play, the Ghost of Christmas Past takes Ebenezer on a terrifying journey. He sees himself as a young man in his 20s. He is with his financee, Belle, who loved him and wanted to marry him, but couldn’t get him to take that final step.

When she came to his workplace to see him there was a pause-- and then Scrooge heard himself say the most pathetic words; he heard himself say “Don’t you know that I can’t take up personal matters at work.”  His fiancee, Belle, realized that work and making money was his life. And so she left him. Scrooge had made his choice, and his choice resulted in his becoming a miserable man.

In Scrooge’s dream, the Ghost of Christmas Future came along next, and showed Scrooge how his life in the future was going to continue to be wretchedly unhappy.

One final ghost came to him -- The Ghost of Christmas Present. This Ghost gave Scrooge one final opportunity to change, to make a new decision, a good decision, for the people around him - for Tiny Tim -- and his family and all the other people whom Scrooge had abused through the years. This time, Scrooge didn’t pause very long at all. He made the right decision, and experienced happiness for the first time.  It’s such a beautiful story.

The Magi made the right decision when they first set off on their long and arduous journey, and again they made the right decision when they left Jerusalem and headed south for Bethlehem. And God rewarded them by letting "the star they had seen in the east go ahead of them until it stopped over the place where the child was. When they saw the star, they were overjoyed.” (Mt 2:9,10)

How kind it was of God to do this for them-- to give them this reassurance. God does this for us often.  He (1) puts a desire in our hearts; and then (2) he gives us a promise or direction from his Word, and before the promise is fulfilled he (3) reassures us in one way or another that we are on the right track. The star reappeared, there it was shining over the place where the child was -- they were on the right track. It was like the Ghost of Christmas Present letting Ebenezer know that he was finally on the right track.

But the huge question of the Christmas Carol by William Dix remains with us -- “What child is this?”  What will be our answer? What’s our response? Are we going to stay put like the chief priests and the teachers of the law. Are we going to avoid taking up personal matters at work, just stay involved in our busy schedules, just carry on without any interruptions?  

There may be people, like Herod, who would like to destroy the Christ child. But there is no way that anyone can do that. The Carols cannot be silenced. Starting in November, they sneak up on you in department stores, on the air waves, in the novelty shops. There was no way that Herod or anyone else could silence Jesus.  He himself said, “No one takes my life from me, but I lay it down of my own accord.” (Jn 10:18)   

So there is this great pause, and we get to decide.  Will we be afraid of what others think, our peers, our co-workers, our families.  Will they say that we are becoming too religious? Too involved with church and the Bible and Christianity?

C. S. Lewis, has a wonderful statement in the Chronicles of Narnia, the Silver Chair that relates to all of this.  Jill’s friend falls over a cliff. And Jill sees the great Lion Aslan and she is frightened, being on a cliff all alone in a strange place and seeing this great Lion, and she cries and cries, and C. S. Lewis comes up with one of his greatest lines: “Crying is all right in a way-- as long as it lasts -- but sooner or later you have to stop and then you have to decide what to do.”  

It’s true in so many ways:
- Playing soccer is all right in a way-- as long as it lasts -- but sooner or later you have to stop and then you have to decide what to do.”
- Grieving is all right in a way --  as long as it lasts [you don’t want to tell a person to stop grieving] -- but sooner or later that person has to stop and then decide what to do.  
- “Touring Paris is all right in a way -- as long as it lasts -- but sooner or later you have to stop and then you have to decide what to do.”
- Going to school is all right in a way -- as long as it lasts -- but sooner or later you have to stop and then you have to decide what to do.  
- Singing Christmas Carols and reading the Christmas Story and hearing sermons on the Christ Child is all right in a way -- as long as it lasts --  but sooner or later you have to stop and decide what to do.”  

“What child is this?”  There are many answers to the question.  Here’s a surprising response from none other than Napoleon Bonaparte.  He said,

"I know men and I tell you that Jesus Christ is no mere man.  Between Him and every other person in the world there is no possible term of comparison.  Alexander, Caesar, Charlemagne, and I have founded empires.  But on what did we rest the creations of our genius?  Upon force.  Jesus Christ founded His empire upon love; and at this hour millions of men would die for Him."

“What child is this?” It is very important how you decide. Here’s how William Dix responds to the question in the final stanza of his carol: “So bring Him incense, gold and myrrh,
Come peasant, king to own Him;
The King of kings salvation brings,
Let loving hearts enthrone Him.”

We’ve taken a pause so that you could think of your response. What's it going to be?  A loving heart?  Worship? Will you enthrone Him? Will you let him rule your life? What's your response?  Amen.